DECATUR -- Charges of beating and robbing a deaf Decatur victim have been dismissed against Brian O. Cunningham.

Cunningham, 25, had pleaded not guilty to charges of armed robbery, aggravated robbery and mob action. Those charges were dismissed at a hearing Friday in Macon County Circuit Court. They were dismissed “without prejudice” which means they could be re-filed if new evidence becomes available.

Macon County State’s Attorney Jay Scott said Monday the case against Cunningham collapsed because of repeated inconsistencies in the story told by the 46-year-old victim, who is profoundly deaf. Scott said there is no doubt the victim was beaten and robbed on May 4, 2018, during which his $1,000 hearing aids were ripped out of his ears, he was punched and had a gun held to his face before being robbed of $400 in cash. He was treated at a hospital following the attack.

But Scott said the victim told different versions of what happened in a series of interviews with an assistant state’s attorney and a victim advocate.

“There were just multiple inconsistencies with what was originally reported to the police,” added Scott. “We’ve got a burden of proof to meet and we don’t want to try to convict somebody where we don’t have the evidence and it was clear that, when it came to Mr. Cunningham, we didn’t have the evidence to convict him.”

Another Decatur man, Adrian E. Batts, pleaded guilty to a charge of aggravated robbery in the same case and was sentenced to 24 months probation at a hearing in October.

Subscribe to Daily Headlines

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Contact Tony Reid at (217) 421-7977. Follow him on Twitter: @TonyJReid


Macon County Courts Reporter

Macon County courts reporter for the Herald & Review.

Load comments