Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
30 Decatur teachers reprimanded for not following remote learning grading guidelines
editor's pick top story

30 Decatur teachers reprimanded for not following remote learning grading guidelines


DECATUR — Thirty Decatur public school teachers have been issued reprimands for failing to follow grading guidelines put in place for remote learning, a union official said, with some educators saying the district’s expectations are unfeasible.

“So my questions tonight are these. When will the micromanaging stop? When will teachers be allowed to make mistakes without facing potential discipline around topics which have always been a conversation before now?” said Chrissy Petitt, president of the Decatur Education Association teachers' union, during a school board meeting this week. “When will the 'gotchas' stop? The culture we are currently teaching in is toxic at best.”

All Decatur classes have been taught virtually this academic year because of COVID-19. Sixteen district educators spoke or submitted comments for the Tuesday school board meeting, all pointing to issues with the pacing of lessons, grading procedures and oversight by administration.

Johns Hill Magnet School teacher Heather Samonds said the pacing guides and grading guidelines are unrealistic during remote learning, and teachers are receiving emails late on Friday afternoons scolding them for something they've done and ruining their weekends.

“Teachers need flexibility to give our students what they need,” she said. “We are educated professionals, and we need leadership to help us.”

Denise Swarthout, a spokeswoman for the district, on Wednesday did not respond to a request from the Herald & Review to comment about the remarks made by teachers. 

The school board has a policy of members and administrators not responding to public comments during meetings. At times, the district superintendent will ask for contact information from someone speaking for a follow-up conversation, but that didn’t occur Tuesday.

Illinois schools shut down in mid-March because of COVID-19. As infection numbers declined this summer, school systems decided whether to have in-person or remote learning or a mix.

The state board has said that schools are expected to conduct learning, give grades and require attendance as usual, whether students are meeting in person or virtually.

The district has about 8,700 students. 

Assistant Superintendent Jeff Dase on Tuesday said he’ll meet with teachers to work through issues. He said remote learning was not designed to deliver instruction long-term, but rather fill in during an emergency, although they now need to make it work.

“Ultimately, if we do not get this right, we are just passing the buck,” Dase said, adding later, “Is it harder during virtual learning, yes, but at the end of the day we cannot shift down and take a backseat. These are our kids' lives we're talking about and they still have to get this instruction and we need all hands on deck.”

MacArthur High School student Daniel Flores on Tuesday also brought up concerns.

Support Local Journalism

Your membership makes our reporting possible.

“The workload is immense compared to going in person,” said Flores, who is a student ambassador to the board. “It's doable, but students have to devote most of their day to it.”

Last school year, the state relaxed certain requirements as schools shifted to remote learning. That did not happen this year.

Andrew Matthews, representative of the Illinois Education Association, said 30 educators so far have been issued reprimands for failing to follow new grading guidelines, that classes are larger than the DEA contract calls for and that teachers are being held accountable for students who are not engaging in remote learning.

Matthews during the board meeting on Tuesday compared the district's current climate to a nuclear power plant with alarms and sirens going off and no one paying attention to them. He said communication between the union and board is non-existent.

“This isn't how it works in other districts. You have a chance to listen or you can have Chernobyl,” he said.

Jalyn Pearce, who attends Eisenhower, also spoke of the heavy workload and the difficulty being experienced by some students who have trouble getting online and learning enough to do their homework from online sessions.

“It's becoming unhealthy for the mental well-being of students,” she said. “We need more time with teachers for extra help. Students are struggling, and this is a lot of kids, this is from freshmen to seniors, MacArthur and Eisenhower both, people in AP, honors and regular classes.”

Decatur is one of the only districts in the region to have been entirely remote since the academic year started. Officials have said that they are closely monitoring health data and may return to class as numbers improve. Another announcement is expected on Oct. 30.

Dace said parents must also do their part. Parent-teacher conferences, most held virtually, will be in the next two weeks.

“This is the opportunity to ask these questions,” Dase said. “How did my child earn that grade? A standards-based approach allows parents to understand more clearly what is expected of students and how to help them be successful in their learning.”

Petitt said that teachers will follow up with the district in the hope of resolution. 

“Life is hard right now for everyone,” she said. “Parents, students, and teachers need to know you have their back.”

Updated: This story has been updated to clarify that the Herald & Review asked for comments from the Decatur school district about the remarks by teachers. 

7 of Decatur's most historic homes

Contact Valerie Wells at (217) 421-7982. Follow her on Twitter: @modgirlreporter


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Illinois' top public health official urged residents on Wednesday to prepare for holiday celebrations differently this year as the state conti…

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News