Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Republicans request Root be declared official winner of Macon County sheriff's race
breaking top story

Republicans request Root be declared official winner of Macon County sheriff's race

Macon County sheriff

Democrat Tony Brown, left, and Republican Jim Root

DECATUR — The Macon County Republican Party announced Monday it will not only ask for a full recount of the results of the sheriff’s race, but that it wants its candidate Jim Root to be declared the elected sheriff.

In a letter sent to the Macon County Clerk's Office and obtained by the Herald & Review, the GOP is asking for the clerk, the local election authority, to reverse the Nov. 6 results that saw Democrat Tony Brown defeat Root by a single vote, 19,655 to 19,654.

Brown_Tony 4 11.30.18.JPG

Tony Brown is sworn in as Macon County sheriff on Friday afternoon at the Macon County Law Enforcement Center. 

During Friday’s discovery recount, when Root and the Republicans were allowed to review up to 25 percent of Macon County’s 72 precincts, two uncounted ballots for Root were discovered in a Hickory Point precinct.

“The immediate correction, recall/withdrawal of the November 20, 2018 Proclamation that Tony 'Chubby' Brown was duly elected and issuance of a Proclamation that Jim Root is the duly elected Sheriff of Macon County by a count of 19,656 for Root to 19,655 for Brown is hereby demanded,” says the document.

Root, who said he was aware of the letter, declined to comment when reached by text Monday afternoon.

Brown, who was sworn in as sheriff on Friday, said after Monday night's county board meeting that, in his view, the election is over. Unless the courts say otherwise, Brown said he is focused on being sheriff and working to bring the department together for the betterment of the community.

"I'm not concerned about all this stuff right now," Brown said.

Macon County Republican Party Chairman Bruce Pillsbury confirmed the validity of the request and said with the evidence gathered during Friday’s discovery request, Root should be declared the actual winner of the race.

“If anything, that proclamation should be recalled,” Pillsbury said, referring to the announcement that Brown was the official winner and his subsequent swearing-in as sheriff to replace Howard Buffett.

Macon County Democratic Party Chairman Jim Underwood did not return a message on his cell phone seeking comment.

Scott, Jay


Monday’s news comes less than 72 hours since Root and the Republicans conducted a discovery recount at the clerk's office, when evidence can be gathered for a potential request for a full recount, which must be filed in Macon County Circuit Court.

How the two ballots for Root went uncounted on election night was a mystery to then-Clerk Steve Bean.

Root_Jim 11.30.18

Jim Root, republican candidate for Macon County Sheriff, middle, speaks with attorney Jerry Stocks while observing the discovery recount for the Macon County Sheriff’s race at the Macon County Office Building Friday morning.

He said Friday that the ballots were discovered a few days after the Nov. 6 election among the “spoiled ballots,” or those ballots deemed invalid, with a note that said they should be counted. On election night, Root initially had a 99-vote lead. On Nov. 20, provisional and mail-in ballots were added, and Brown received a 1-vote margin of victory.

Bean said Friday he could not get an answer from the election judges about the note or why the ballots were not counted on election night.

Tony Brown 2

Macon County Sheriff's Lt. Jim Root, right, hugs Sheriff Tony Brown after Brown is sworn in on Friday. Root is seeking a discovery recount after election results showed Brown winning by one vote. 

A combination of factors, from handling attorney questions to handling provisional and mail-in ballots and health issues from Bean, caused the ballots to not be tabulated with the rest of the provisional and mail-in ballots on Nov. 20. Bean notified the Republicans before Friday of the existence of the two ballots.

Local and state officials have previously said it would be up to the court to change the results of the election. But the Republican request cites a part of the Illinois Election Code that covers how ballots are retabulated as evidence for why the results should be reversed without the need for a court order.

Macon County State’s Attorney Jay Scott said after Monday night's county board meeting that his office had not yet finished their review of the request.

Macon County Clerk Josh Tanner, whose first day in office was Monday, said he is aware of the request and was waiting for advice from Scott’s office on how to proceed.

Contact Ryan Voyles at (217) 421-7985. Follow him on Twitter: @RVVoyles


Get Election 2020 & Politics updates in your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News