You are the owner of this article.
How does your garden grow? Decatur council considers allowing native prairie plants taller than 10 inches
breaking top story

How does your garden grow? Decatur council considers allowing native prairie plants taller than 10 inches

DOMINANT - Carmichael_Don 1 7.13.19.JPG

Don Carmichael, center, shows off his garden while giving a tour to members of the nature organization SONA on Saturday. Carmichael and SONA members appeared at the Decatur City Council on Monday to ask for a moratorium on city rules that would require him to mow down the plants. 

DECATUR — City leaders will explore new rules that would allow residents to grow native prairie gardens on their properties, a move previously not allowed by city code that requires grass to be 10 inches or shorter.

Council members on Monday voted 6-1 to place a moratorium on enforcing the weed maintenance ordinance on potential prairie gardens. City staff have two months to consult with local and state environmental experts and form new rules for the council to consider.

“This pause gives the city time to research and develop rules based on expert opinions and advice,” City Manager Scot Wrighton said.

SECONDARY - Carmichael_Don 5 7.13.19.JPG

A bee lands on a bee balm plant in Don Carmichael's Decatur garden. Carmichael has long sought the ability to cultivate his garden of what he says are native prairie plants, despite a city ordinance that outlaws grasses taller than 10 inches.

He stressed that the measure did not repeal the current weeds ordinance, but rather allowed for a narrow exception for properties that city staff felt could be considered legitimate prairie gardens. Under city code, property owners with weeds taller than 10 inches are typically given a $150 fine; if they don’t cut the grass after that, the city can mow the lawn and bill the property owner for the expense.

The vote came as welcome news to local environmentalists who spoke to the council at the start of the meeting. Among them was Don Carmichael, a Decatur resident who has campaigned for years in Herald & Review letters to the editor and appearances at council meetings to be allowed to maintain his yard full of yellow and purple wildflowers and other prairie plants.

Sutman_Reed 7.13.19.JPG

Reed Sutman, chairman of the local Sustain Our Natural Areas (SONA) group, takes a photo of flowers during a tour of Don Carmichael's yard in Decatur. 

“The best thing we can do as homeowners is at least use a piece of our backyard to grow homes for insects that help our environment,” Carmichael said.

The moratorium also came with support from advocates and nature conservation organizations such as the Decatur Audubon Society and Sustain Our Natural Areas (SONA). Jim Spaniol, a member of SONA, said the current ordinance hurts the habitats where pollinators native to Illinois could live.

Carmichael_Don 4 7.13.19.JPG

Members of nature organization Sustain Our Natural Areas (SONA) tour Decatur resident Don Carmichael's yard filled with prairie grass on Saturday. 

“Being required to cut your lawn is one thing,” he said, “but having to cut down prairie gardens where bees, butterflies and hummingbirds live is something we shouldn't be obligated to do.”

Councilman Pat McDaniel was the lone “no” vote on the measure. He said the moratorium could lead to residents claiming they were growing a prairie garden while letting their grass get out of hand.

Carmichael_Don 2 7.13.19.JPG

Decatur resident Don Carmichael says he has worked to make his yard a home for native prairie grasses and plants.  

Several council members who voted for the “pause” expressed some reservations about making permanent changes to city code. Councilman Chuck Kuhle asked what could happen to the property values of homes next to prairie gardens.

Wrighton said the city could craft different rules for gardens in residential areas as opposed to those in parks and rural areas. Also, prairie gardens require specific types of plants and maintenance, he said. Simply allowing grass to grow tall is a nuisance, not a garden.

“You’re going to have to put work into it,” Wrighton said. “If you don’t want to put work into it and it grows wild, it’s going to get mowed down.”

Carmichael_Don 3 7.13.19.JPG

The bee balm plant, such as this one in Don Carmichael's Decatur yard, is very attractive to bees, butterflies and hummingbirds.

One endangered species that could benefit from having more prairie gardens is the monarch butterfly. According to the Illinois Department of Natural Resources, monarchs and 130 other insects feed on milkweed nectar and other native wildflowers commonly found in prairie gardens. There are 23 milkweed species native to Illinois; five are endangered in the state, and one is on the federal endangered and threatened species list.

Spaniol at a previous council meeting asked the city to join the National Wildlife Federation’s Mayors’ Monarch Pledge by creating a monarch butterfly garden in Decatur, a proposal to which the council has not yet responded. Councilman David Horn said during the meeting he felt the pledge is important to support because if the city doesn’t, it sends the wrong message. Horn also said the money the city spends on mowing vacant lots could dramatically decrease if the current ordinance was altered to allow for more prairie gardens.

“We spent $180,000 last year on mowing vacant lots and I don’t think that is an effective use of taxpayer dollars,” Horn said. “Management of city gardens is less expensive.”

David Horn


City staff are expected to reach out to other communities as they craft proposed new rules over the next 60 days. The council could accept the new rules or decide to keep the ordinance as-is.

Contact Analisa Trofimuk at (217) 421-7985. Follow her on Twitter: @AnalisaTro


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News