A new study shoots down the notion that medical marijuana laws can prevent opioid overdose deaths, challenging a favorite talking point of legal pot advocates.
Researchers repeated an analysis that sparked excitement years ago. The previous work linked medical marijuana laws to slower than expected increases in state prescription opioid death rates from 1999 to 2010. The original authors speculated patients might be substituting marijuana for painkillers, but they warned against drawing conclusions.
Still, states ravaged by painkiller overdose deaths began to rethink marijuana, leading several to legalize pot for medical use. Illinois is among them: The state first legalized medical marijuana in 2015, and lawmakers this spring passed a measure legalizing recreational use of cannabis that Gov. J.B. Pritzker is expected to sign.
When the new researchers included data through 2017, they found the reverse: States passing medical marijuana laws saw a 23% higher than expected rate of deaths involving prescription opioids.
Legalizing medical marijuana "is not going to be a solution to the opioid overdose crisis," said Chelsea Shover of Stanford University School of Medicine. "It would be wonderful if that were true, but the evidence doesn't suggest that it is."
Shover and colleagues reported the findings Monday in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. It's unlikely, they said, that medical marijuana laws caused first one big effect and then the opposite. Any beneficial link was likely coincidental all along.
"We don't think it's reasonable to say it was saving lives before but it's killing people now," Shover said.
In the opioid crisis, dozens of forces are playing out across the nation in different ways. How widely available is the overdose antidote naloxone? Who has insurance? How broadly does insurance cover addiction treatment?
What's more, prescription pills once were involved in the largest share of overdose deaths, but that changed as heroin and then fentanyl surged. The studies on marijuana laws and opioid deaths don't account for that.
The new study undermines recent policy changes in some states. Last week, New Mexico joined New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania in approving marijuana for patients with opioid addiction.
"I was told my paper helped change the law in New York. I was appalled," said Rosalie Liccardo Pacula of the Rand Drug Policy Research Center. She co-authored a 2018 study on marijuana laws and overdose deaths.
You have free articles remaining.
In Illinois, former Gov. Bruce Rauner in August 2018 signed a law allowing medical marijuana to be used as a painkiller instead of opioids. Advocates said the measure would allow patients to choose another option besides the highly addictive drugs often used to treat pain.
In 2017, there were 2,202 drug overdose deaths involving opioids in Illinois, according to the National Institute on Drug Abuse. That's a rate of 17.2 deaths per 100,000 persons, which is higher than the national rate of 14.6 deaths per 100,000 persons.
Rauner last fall called the medical marijuana expansion an "important step."
"We want to make sure there just aren't manipulations to just expand marijuana pervasiveness throughout our society. That said, cannabis can clearly have a benefit for pain management," the Republican former governor said.
"It is addictive, but it's less addictive than opioids, so making that available as an alternative, where otherwise opioids would be prescribed, I think that was a positive step for the people of Illinois."
Illinois lawmakers passed a bill earlier this month to expand the state's medical marijuana program to include chronic pain, autism and irritable bowel syndrome as qualifying conditions. The program has added more than 12,500 patients since February, when the state ended fingerprint and background check requirements for patients. Nearly 67,000 patients were enrolled in the program in early May.
Experts agree evidence doesn't support marijuana as a treatment for opioid addiction. Drugs like buprenorphine, morphine and naltrexone should be used instead, Pacula said.
Marijuana has been shown to help ease chronic pain, and other studies have suggested medical marijuana laws may reduce opioid prescribing. So there's still reason to believe that for some people, marijuana can substitute for opioids as a pain reliever.
As for addiction and the overdose crisis, "we should focus our research and policies on other questions that might make a difference," Shover said.
Authors of the original research welcomed the new analysis.
"We weren't happy when a billboard went up saying marijuana laws reduce overdose deaths," said Brendan Saloner of Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. "That was very hard for us to rein in."