There's a moment right before your pizza order comes together, when you're staring at a list of toppings and crust styles, that separates the casual diner from someone who really knows what they want. At Aurelio's Pizza, that moment is the whole point.
Since 1959, Aurelio's has built its reputation in Homewood, Illinois, on traditional Italian pizza made the way it should be — thin crust, careful sauce, real ingredients. But the create-your-own-pizza option adds something extra: control. You decide what goes on your pie, and the result actually tastes like your decision.
Start With the Crust
Every good pizza starts with the base, and this is where your build begins. A thin, crisp crust lets toppings shine and gives you that classic snap with each bite. It's a foundation built on decades of practice, not a shortcut.
Whether you're feeding a family of six or ordering a personal pie for lunch, the crust sets the tone for everything that follows.
Sauce and Cheese: The Non-Negotiables
Aurelio's sauce recipe reflects the restaurant's Italian roots — nothing overly sweet, nothing bland. Paired with a generous layer of cheese, it creates the kind of base that holds up to bold toppings without getting lost underneath them.
This is the part of the process where less experienced pizza makers cut corners. Aurelio's doesn't.
Choosing Your Toppings: Where the Fun Starts
Here's where create-your-own-pizza really earns its name. You can go classic with pepperoni and mushrooms, or take a chance on something with more personality.
Calabrese pizza fans already know what they're after: a spicy sausage that brings real heat and depth to every slice. Pair it with roasted red peppers and a light drizzle of olive oil, and you've got something that feels like a trip through an Italian countryside kitchen — minus the plane ticket.
If you're a fan of Italian beef, consider working it into your pizza build for a hearty, meat-forward pie that eats more like a meal than a snack. Combine it with giardiniera for a little kick, or keep it simple with extra mozzarella and a touch of garlic.
Families with picky eaters will appreciate how easy it is to split the difference — pepperoni and cheese on one half, a loaded veggie combination on the other. Nobody has to compromise when everyone gets to build their own.
Topping Pairings Worth Trying
A few combinations worth experimenting with:
Calabrese sausage with banana peppers and onion delivers a balance of spice and sweetness that works well for those who like a little heat without overwhelming the whole pie.
Italian sausage, mushroom, and green pepper is a classic for a reason — it's the kind of combination that never goes out of style at a traditional Italian pizza restaurant.
For something lighter, try fresh tomato, basil, and extra cheese. It's simple, but it lets the crust and sauce do the talking.
Why It Matters for Families and Local Diners
Pizza night works best when everyone gets a say. The create-your-own-pizza format at Aurelio's makes that possible without turning dinner into a negotiation. It's practical for families, satisfying for pizza lovers who like to experiment, and simple enough for casual diners who just want something good without overthinking it.
And because Aurelio's offers dine-in, takeout, and pizza delivery, you can build your pizza and enjoy it exactly how you want — at the restaurant, at home, or wherever the evening takes you.
Don't Forget the Rewards
Regular visitors should look into the Aurelio's pizza rewards app, which gives loyal customers a way to get more out of every order. If pizza night is already part of your routine, it's worth having in your back pocket.
For larger get-togethers, Aurelio's pizza catering service extends the same customization options to bigger crowds, so office lunches and family gatherings don't have to mean settling for one-size-fits-all options.
Time to Build Your Own
The next step is simple: pick your crust, choose your sauce, load up on toppings like Calabrese sausage or Italian beef, and see what you come up with. Visit Aurelio's Pizza to start your order online, or head to the Homewood, Illinois location to build your pie in person. Either way, your perfect pizza is closer than you think.
Lee Enterprises newsrooms were not involved in the creation of this content.
